Exam 1

  1. Metainformation

    Tag Value
    fileInferential_Statistics_vufsw-mediation-1033-en_vufsw-mediation-1033-en
    namevufsw-mediation-1033-en
    sectioninferential statistics/regression/multiple linear regression/mediation
    typeschoice
    solutionFALSE, FALSE, FALSE, TRUE
    Typeconceptual
    ProgramNA
    LanguageEnglish
    Levelstatistical reasoning

    Question

    Which of the following is not one of the disadvantages of Baron and Kenny’s method to assess mediation?


    1. FALSE: Baron and Kenny rely too much on the statistical significance of c and c’
    2. FALSE: Baron and Kenny suggest the testing of the significance of and b. However, mediation is assessed by the significance of the indirect effect ab which is not the same as testing of the significance of and separately.
    3. FALSE: The condition that a total effect c should exist is not necessary
    4. TRUE: The condition that an indirect effect ab should exist is not necessary

    Solution

    The three disadvantages of the Baron and Kenny method are the following:

    1. Baron and Kenny rely too much on the statistical significance of c and c’. So, if c’=.5 (P=0.049) we conclude that there is mediation while if c’=.5 (P=0.051), we conclude that there is no mediation

    2. Baron and Kenny suggest the testing of the significance of and b. However, mediation is assessed by the significance of the indirect effect ab which is not the same as testing of the significance of and separately.

    3. The condition that a total effect c should exist is not necessary. This is the case in suppression. 

    Therefore the option “The condition that the indirect effect ab should exist is not necessary” is the correct answer


    1. False
    2. False
    3. False
    4. True